Introduction
It is crucial to shield electrical and electronic parts from various environmental factors for the equipment to function optimally and safely. Selecting the right protective enclosure is therefore a very important decision especially when dealing with the NEMA rating system which is common in North America. Although, there is a clear distinction between the different classes in NEMA, there is often confusion between two specific ratings: NEMA 4 and NEMA 4X.
Although both are designed to provide adequate protection against water and dust, there is a significant difference that determines their application. Failure to understand this distinction can result in additional expenses or, worse, equipment failure at an early stage.
This paper seeks to give a clear distinction between NEMA 4 and NEMA 4X enclosures to ensure that the reader is well equipped with the necessary knowledge to ensure that they select the right enclosure for their specific working conditions.
What are NEMA 4 and NEMA 4X Ratings?
NEMA enclosure ratings are used to describe the level of protection from solids, liquids, and other environmental conditions, as well as the accessibility of hazardous areas. NEMA 4 and NEMA 4X both mean a high level of protection which is suitable for most indoor and outdoor areas that are not hazardous.
NEMA Type 4
According to NEMA 250, a Type 4 enclosure is suitable for indoor or outdoor applications. It offers a high level of protection against solid foreign objects such as:
- Falling dirt
- Windblown dust
- Rain, sleet, snow
- Splashing water
- Hose-directed water (tested according to NEMA 250).
- External ice formation (undamaged by)
A NEMA 4 enclosure is almost dust tight and water tight, and can be washed down, thus suitable for areas where it is washed or exposed to weather conditions.
NEMA Type 4X
A NEMA Type 4X enclosure contains all the characteristics of a NEMA Type 4 enclosure but with one additional feature: protection against corrosion. The “X” particularly refers to this extra safeguard.
Therefore, a NEMA 4X enclosure provides:
- All NEMA Type 4 protections (dust, various water exposures).
- An additional degree of protection against corrosion.
- Protection against external ice formation damages.
This added corrosion resistance makes NEMA 4X required in the areas where chemicals, salinity or any other aggressive substance can affect the material of the enclosure. This resistance is highly dependent on the material used in the construction of the structure. It is essential to note that both ratings are for non-hazardous areas only; for hazardous areas, different NEMA types are used (7, 8, 9).
NEMA 4 vs 4X: The Critical “X” Factor Explained
The only difference between NEMA 4 and NEMA 4X is that the latter requires corrosion protection to be mandatory. This “X” factor takes into account the susceptibility of the enclosure materials to degradation in harsh environments.
Although NEMA 4 enclosures protect against contaminants, their construction materials (frequently painted carbon steel) are not expected to resist corrosion. In coastal areas, where there is a lot of salt spray, chemical processing plants where there are fumes and spills, or food production plants where there are sanitizing agents, a standard NEMA 4 enclosure can rust or degrade. This weakens its structure and its ability to seal, which leads to the exposure of the internal parts.
NEMA 4X directly combats this. The standard calls for materials that are inherently resistant to the common corrosive agents. This makes sure that the enclosure not only shields its contents but also retains its physical structure throughout its useful life in a corrosive environment.
It is important to note that the term corrosion resistance is not absolute but rather comparative to the corrosive environment and the NEMA 4X material. Various types of stainless steel have varying degrees of resistance to certain chemicals, while non-metallic materials such as fiberglass or polycarbonate also have their own levels of resistance. Hence, it is crucial to determine the particular environmental corrosive factors to be able to choose the correct NEMA 4X enclosure.
In other words, if the operating environment is likely to cause corrosion to the enclosure itself, then NEMA 4X is mandatory. If the main threats are dust, water, and weather with little or no corrosive components, then NEMA 4 might be adequate.
NEMA 4 vs 4X: Materials Compared
The functional requirements, especially corrosion resistance, define the materials used for NEMA 4 and 4X enclosures.
NEMA 4 Enclosure Materials
- Painted Carbon Steel: The most common option. The first line of defense against moisture is a paint layer, which can be a powder coat or a wet coat. The paint can be damaged and this will reduce its durability especially if it is used in areas that are frequently exposed to moisture or if it is used in outdoor facilities.
- Galvanized Steel: Zinc coating is better than paint in terms of corrosion resistance but is not immune to corrosion and may corrode in specific chemical conditions.
- Aluminum: Some of them are resistant to atmospheric corrosion and are lightweight but may be less strong than steel and are prone to certain chemical or galvanic corrosion.
These materials offer protection against NEMA 4 test environments but they are not resistant to corrosive agents in the long run.
NEMA 4X Enclosure Materials
These materials have an inherent ability to resist corrosion:
- Stainless Steel: A popular material used often due to its strength and ability to not rust.
- Type 304:This is the most versatile grade that is used in a wide range of food, pharmaceutical, and industrial environments that require frequent wash down but not high chloride content.
- Type 316: It has better resistance compared to the basic grade especially to chloride (salt) environments, thus suitable for marine, effluent and some chemical environments. It is important to ensure that the welding and finishing of stainless steel are done correctly to retain the properties of the material.
- Fiberglass Reinforced Polyester (FRP): It has excellent chemical resistance, low weight and electrical conductivity. It is commonly used in chemical industries and other outdoor facilities. May need UV stabilizers for long-term outdoor use.
- Polycarbonate: High impact resistance, UV stability, and good chemical resistance (variable). Light in weight and commonly used in instrumentation or control panels.
- Aluminum Alloys: Some specific types can achieve 4X standards especially for marine applications, which provide corrosion resistance and light weight.
When choosing the right NEMA 4X material, it is crucial to consider the resistance of the material to certain chemicals, temperature, UV radiation, impact, and cost. The quality of fabrication, seals, and hardware is also critical in maintaining NEMA compliance in the long run.
NEMA 4 vs 4X: Cost Considerations
Price is usually the main consideration between NEMA 4 and 4X. In general, NEMA 4X enclosures are more expensive than NEMA 4 enclosures at the initial stage due to the cost of stainless steel or other polymers used in the construction of the enclosure as compared to carbon steel coated with a protective layer.
However, focusing only on the initial cost is not very wise. A Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) analysis gives a better perspective. TCO is the initial cost of the product plus the cost of operating it for its lifetime, maintenance cost, and the cost of failure.
Thus, although the NEMA 4 enclosure is cheaper initially when used in a corrosive environment, it can result in:
- Corrosion leads to early failure of the enclosure and seals.
- Costly damage to internal equipment.
- Significant operational downtime and lost production.
- The cost of repeated replacement of the enclosure and the labor cost involved in the process.
- Potential safety hazards.
Selecting the right NEMA 4X enclosure for the right environment may be more expensive in the beginning but it leads to a lower TCO because of:
- Extended lifespan due to material durability.
- Fewer maintenance requirements due to corrosion.
- Reliable, continuous protection for internal components.
- Minimized risk of costly downtime.
The best solution is one that is properly aligned with the environment to minimize the dangers of under-designing and the inefficiency of over-designing.
NEMA 4 vs NEMA 4X: Comprehensive Comparison Table
| Feature | NEMA 4 | NEMA 4X |
| Dust Protection | Prevents entry of dust and solid objects, dust-tight | Prevents entry of dust and solid objects, dust-tight |
| Water Protection | Protects against rain, snow, splashing water, hose-directed water | Same as NEMA 4, with higher water protection capability |
| Corrosion Resistance | No requirement; materials may corrode (e.g., painted carbon steel or galvanized steel) | Must have corrosion resistance, uses corrosion-resistant materials (e.g., stainless steel, fiberglass) |
| Ice Resistance | Resistant to external ice formation without damage | Same as NEMA 4, but better suited for corrosive environments with ice |
| Common Applications | General manufacturing, outdoor infrastructure (non-corrosive environments) | Food processing, pharmaceuticals, marine, chemical plants, wastewater treatment |
| Material Options | Painted carbon steel, galvanized steel, aluminum | Stainless steel (304, 316), fiberglass, polycarbonate, corrosion-resistant aluminum alloys |
| Durability | Shorter lifespan in corrosive environments, may require frequent replacement | Longer lifespan, especially in corrosive environments |
| IP Rating | IP56: Dust-tight (complete protection) and water-tight (against sprays, rain) | IP66/IP67: Dust-tight (complete protection) and water-tight (against spray, immersion) |
| Cost | $ | $$$ |
Need Custom Metal Enclosures? TZR Sheet Metal Solutions
Standard NEMA 4 and 4X enclosures might not always be suitable for specific projects considering size, component layout, or mounting. Attempting to use standard units results in inefficient compromise that can lead to poor space utilization and risk the structural integrity of an enclosure. In cases where specific metal enclosures are required to be fabricated for specific applications and in accordance with NEMA specifications, then specialized fabrication is the way to go.
TZR is unmatched when it comes to delivering high-quality, precision components crafted specifically to your design requirements. Being a leading of the sheet metal fabricator for the automotive, medical, 3D printers, and renewable energy industries, we have superb capabilities in a diversity of materials such as steel, stainless steel, aluminum, copper, and brass. Providing advanced processes such as laser cutting, CNC punching and precision bending, subscribed to stringent production standards, in the ISO regard, surpassing quality regulations, along with a 98% quality yield rate proves this claim. Partner with TZR for expertly tailored NEMA enclosure solutions.
NEMA 4 vs 4X: Application Scenarios Compared
The decision between NEMA 4 and 4X is based on the presence of corrosive substances or not.
Typical NEMA 4 Applications (Corrosion Not a Major Factor):
- General Manufacturing: Control panels in normal industrial environment where exposed to dust or non-corrosive wash down.
- Outdoor Infrastructure (Non-Coastal/Chemical): Traffic signals and other control devices, enclosures, cabinets, and boxes that are located outside but not in a marine environment or near chemicals.
- Indoor Non-Corrosive Washdown: Areas that are washed with water hose without using any chemicals.
- Warehousing & Logistics: Automation of conveyors, sorters.
Common Uses of NEMA 4X Enclosures (Corrosion is an Issue):
- Food & Beverage: Due to the constant use of water and sanitizers, the enclosures are required to be NEMA 4X, sometimes made of stainless steel.
- Pharmaceuticals: Similar requirements for cleanability and resistance to process/cleaning chemicals.
- Wastewater Treatment: Exposure to moisture, H₂S, chlorine dictates NEMA 4X (fiberglass or Type 316 SS common).
- Chemical Resistance: Some of the chemical fumes/spills are dangerous and the material used must be resistant to these chemicals.
- Marine/Coastal: Salt spray necessitates NEMA 4X (Type 316 SS, suitable aluminum, or fiberglass).
- Pulp & Paper: Corrosive processing chemicals need NEMA 4X.
- Agriculture: Viscous fumes such as ammonia in livestock buildings require NEMA 4X.
Environmental analysis is very important in any given project. The factors that should be taken into consideration include airborne contaminants, cleaning methods, temperature, and humidity. When borderline conditions are present, NEMA 4X provides a greater level of protection.
Final Thought: Selecting Your Ideal NEMA Enclosure
When deciding between NEMA 4 and NEMA 4X, one has to consider the application environment and the properties of the material and the cost. Both offer identical, high-level protection against dust and water ingress, suitable for harsh conditions.
The key difference is the ‘X’ – denoting extra corrosion protection offered by specific materials in NEMA 4X enclosures.
To make the optimal choice, ask:
- Is it adequate to have only dust and water (hose-down) resistance? (If yes, both 4 and 4X meet the criteria on this point).
- Is there exposure to chemicals, salt, or other harsh cleaning agents? (If yes, NEMA 4X is necessary).
- Is it necessary to consider some characteristics of the material (weight, impact resistance)? (Guides choice among 4X material options).
- What is the budget taking into account Total Cost of Ownership? This is a trade-off between the initial cost of the product and the durability of the product in the long run.
- Should one use standard sizes or should there be a need to go for customization? (If standard compromises are applicable or if they are not applicable then consider custom options).
By comparing the environment with the protection levels, the right NEMA enclosure is chosen to protect your equipment and guarantee long-term functionality.
